Irrelevant Character Assassination

-

 The impeachment trial in the Philippines functions as a hybrid political and judicial proceeding; any expert testimony must be directly relevant to the six constitutional grounds for impeachment, such as a betrayal of public trust or other high crimes. 

Since mental instability itself is not a ground for impeachment, an expert cannot testify merely to declare an official unfit. Even if they may assert relevance, the testimony faces strict legal and ethical hurdles under the Revised Rules on Evidence, particularly if the expert attempts to diagnose a public figure without a direct clinical examination, which violates professional ethics and can be dismissed as speculative by the defense. 

Historical precedents like the 2018 house hearings against Chief Justice Maria Lourdes Sereno was widely condemned by legal scholars as an irrelevant distraction and was criticized as highly politicized tactics for character assassination even if they may argue permissibility. 

It is legally irrelevant, ethically flawed, and an improper weaponization of medical science for political character assassination.

Mental health, psychological stability, or personality traits are not listed as constitutional grounds for impeachment. Any expert testimony analyzing the Vice President’s psyche is entirely irrelevant to determining whether she committed an impeachable crime.

A psychologist or psychiatrist cannot ethically or accurately diagnose or evaluate a public figure without a comprehensive, personal clinical examination. Relying on remote observations of media clips, speeches, or highly publicized political sparring violates the universally recognized "Goldwater Rule" of professional ethics. Allowing an expert to offer speculative, secondhand assessments of the Vice President's intent or state of mind would reduce the Senate Impeachment Court to a forum for unscientific guesswork and inadmissible hearsay.

Political speech—even when aggressive, hyperbolic, or highly charged—must be judged by its political and legal context, not pathologized by handpicked medical professionals. Defending the Vice President against this tactic is essential to upholding due process and ensuring that impeachment remains a strict constitutional mechanism rather than a tool for psychological warfare.

Further, to run for the presidency in the Philippines, a candidate must simultaneously satisfy the strict qualifications of the 1987 Constitution and the eligibility rules of the Omnibus Election Code. Under Article VII, Section 2 of the Constitution, a candidate must be a natural-born citizen of the Philippines, a registered voter, able to read and write, at least 40 years old on the day of the election, and a resident of the country for at least 10 years immediately preceding the vote.

Mental health isn't part of the requirement because that is a contextual matter, depending on what is triggering or rousing a person's anxiety, anger, or depression.

Popular posts from this blog

What to do when you're cloned or spoofed in Facebook?

-
 Facebook identity can may be cloned or spoofed, which is unfortunately a common issue. Here's how and why that happens — and what you can do about it: 1. Profile Cloning (Most Common Cause) - Someone creates fake Facebook profiles using your name, profile picture, and public info. Use variations of your name (e.g., John A. Smith, Jon Smith, J. Smith); Use different photos; send friend requests to your contacts; & attempt scams (e.g., asking for money, promoting fake offers). 2. Data Scraping - Bots can scrape public data from your profile — name, friends list, photos — and use it to generate fake accounts. This is often automated and used for spamming, phishing, & fake engagement on posts or groups. 3. Impersonation as a Form of Harassment or Scam - deliberate impersonation may intend to damage your reputation, confuse network, and trick others (romance scams, crypto schemes) 4.  Facebook Algorithm Loopholes - Facebook’s algorithm may not catch similar profiles immedi...
Read more

Crising, Dante and Emong: typhoons in the tropics and flooding

-
Image
Windy's hurricane tracker forecast of the movement of Tropical Depression Crising. The heavens wept. Dark clouds gathered above the scattered realms and the rains fell in ceaseless torrents — driven by twin tempests: enters typhoon Crising or Wipha in distant tongues, and the ancient monsoon power of Habagat, posing risks and vulnerabilities to the populace. The rivers swelled with wrath, and the winds did howl in majors areas of the archipelago. From the northmost moves to the far southern provinces, floodwaters rose, claiming the streets, the fields, and even the hearths of the humble and great alike. Read updated situational report of the NDRRMC on July 23, 2025, here In that hours, seven regions and twenty-seven provinces were declared under the state of calamity. The National Disaster Risk Reduction and Management Council, or NDRRMC — bore grim tidings: that over 1.9 million souls, had been affected by severe flooding. Elsewhere, in Katipunan, great poles of iron and billboard...
Read more

From Classrooms to Conflict Zones: Protecting Students in High-Risk Community Immersion Areas

-
Image
  This discusses insights about community-based immersion and offers practical standard mechanisms to protect university students engaged in this program, particularly in high-risk community immersion areas and, more critically, in potential conflict zones where latent conflict between rebels and government forces have all the conditions to escalate into violence. It attempts to examine the institutional frameworks, legal considerations, operational protocols, and welfare dimensions crucial for ensuring student safety and well-being during such experiential learning initiatives. The discussion emphasizes the collaborative roles of universities, non-governmental organizations (NGOs), and government agencies in establishing robust protection measures . 1. Introduction University-led community immersion programs are integral to various academic disciplines, including public works, social work, nursing, and social sciences. These programs facilitate experiential learning, data gather...
Read more